Talent Market

Talent Market's mission is to promote liberty by providing talent for critical roles within the free-market nonprofit sector

  • SEND US YOUR RESUME
  • CANDIDATES
    • APPLY FOR YOUR DREAM JOB
    • JOB OPENINGS
    • SIGN UP FOR E-NEWSLETTER
    • CANDIDATE FAQ
  • CLIENTS
    • NEED HELP WITH A SEARCH?
    • OUTREACH
    • GEOGRAPHY & VIRTUAL WORK
    • TIPS FOR HIRING MANAGERS
    • CLIENT LIST
  • RESOURCES
    • ADVICE
      • TALENT TIPS
      • INTERVIEWING TIPS
      • RESUME TIPS
      • PREPARING YOUR RESUME & COVER LETTER
      • CONSIDERING THE NONPROFIT SECTOR?
      • CONSIDERING A CAREER IN FUNDRAISING?
      • ADVICE FOR ATTORNEYS
      • JOB HUNTING RESOURCES
    • INTERNSHIPS, CLERKSHIPS, & FELLOWSHIPS
    • PROFESSIONAL DEVELOPMENT
      • STUDENTS & RECENT GRADUATES
      • MID-CAREER
      • ATTORNEYS
    • AWARDS
      • AWARD WINNERS
    • FREE-MARKET NONPROFIT DIRECTORY
    • FREE-MARKET NONPROFIT MAP
  • ABOUT
    • SUPPORT
    • SIGN UP FOR E-NEWSLETTER
    • OUR TEAM
    • ADVISORY COUNCIL
    • PARTNERSHIP WITH AMERICA’S FUTURE
    • SUCCESS
    • PRIVACY POLICY
    • CONTACT

Talent Tip #104: Don’t Fall in the Homestretch: 5 Tips to Winning the Interview Process

June 20, 2018

When I ran distance races in high school track, I would often do a (very ungraceful) tour jeté as I neared the finish line. 

As you can imagine, my track coach was very displeased with such shenanigans. But I assured him that my goofiness would never cost me a race. After all, the end was so close.

And so it goes with candidates in the interview process. In a candidate’s mind, making it to the interview means you’re in the homestretch. All you have to do now is finish the race, right?

Well, sort of. Remember you’re not alone on that homestretch. Just over your shoulder is another candidate ready to take the lead if you stumble (or pretend to be a ballerina). And trust me: I see a lot of stumbling near the finish line.

Here are five ways to avoid a misstep in the final stages of the interview process.

  1. Treat everyone as you would the boss
    During your interview, there’s a good chance you’ll be interacting with some really important people. For instance, you might meet the president of the organization, a board member, or the receptionist.
    Yep, that’s right. The receptionist is a VIP. Even if you don’t interview with the receptionist, you’ll no doubt interact with him/her, and it’s important that you treat the person with the same respect and courtesy you would anyone else.Why? Because not doing so can easily cost you a job. Case in point, a client recently told me he did not hire a talented mid-level professional because of the way she treated the support staff at the organization. Her behavior implied that these critical team members were “beneath her,” and the organization had no tolerance for such arrogance.
  2. Provide evidence that you can do the job
    If I were a bettin’ gal, I’d wager a large sum of Monopoly money that you’ll be asked at some point during the interview to provide evidence you can do the job. This might take the form of behavioral interviewing (“Tell me about a time in which you…” or “Give me an example of your ability to…”). Or, it may be more straightforward: “Have you done X? Tell me about it.”
    The best way to prepare is to have several good work stories in mind that illustrate your ability to handle the main responsibilities outlined in the job description. A really good story will speak to various skills and can be used to answer different types of questions. Depending on the specific question you’re asked, you can emphasize different aspects of the story to provide a relevant answer.Not being prepared in this arena can be a critical misstep. A candidate I adore told me after an interview that he had bombed it. “They asked me several behavioral questions and I totally blanked on good examples to share.” Sadly, he was right. The client liked him, but without evidence he could do the job, they opted for another candidate.
  3. Be prepared to talk salary
    I am shocked how many job applicants say things such as this during job interviews: “Oh, I wasn’t ready to talk about salary.”
    What? Did a band of rouge garden gnomes fill out the job application for you and then bring you to the interview against your will? The horror!Come on, people. If you’re on the job market, you need to be thinking critically about your salary requirements. Before you apply for a job (let alone walk into an interview), you should have already done your homework  and have a good sense of where you need to be financially.

    If you’re not prepared to provide a salary range when asked, you should hold off on applying for jobs until you can.

  4. Ask for business cards and send a hand-written thank you note
    As each of your interviews wrap up, make sure to ask the person across the table for a business card. Why? Because unless you’re Rainman, you won’t be able to remember everyone’s name. And even if you do, you can’t be sure of the spelling (he said “Joe Smith” but what if it’s spelled Throatwobbler Mangrove?).
    And why do you need to know how to spell his name? Because you’re going to send a hand-written thank you note promptly after the interview!I know what you’re thinking. It’s 2018. Won’t an email suffice? Maybe. But why take the chance?

    From a client earlier this month: “We liked all of the candidates we interviewed in the last round. XXXXX was the only one who didn’t follow-up with a thank you note. Since this role is focused on relationship building, we’ve eliminated her from the running.”

  5. Keep in touch and remain responsive
    After the interview is over, don’t just sit around and passively wait to hear from the organization. If a week has gone by and you’re hearing crickets, send a nice follow-up email asking if you can provide any additional information and reiterating your interest in the role.
    While I believe the onus is on the hiring organization to make the next move, your proactive approach may help you stand out from the crowd.I often hear things like this from clients: We’re still deciding to whom we want to offer the job, but I’m leaning toward Suzy. I’ve been impressed with her follow-up; it’s clear she really wants the job.

    And if the organization does reach out to you post-interview, be responsive! I just witnessed a client withdraw an offer for a candidate because he had become unresponsive in the days following the interview. My guess is that the candidate was employing his old high school dating tactics (playing hard to get). Apparently that approach works as well now as it did back then.

If you’re wondering, my awful dance moves never did cost me a race.  Maybe some pride or a prom date, but it was worth it.  

Keyword Search

Category Search

Talent Tips Archive Search

SEND US YOUR RESUME

If you want us to keep you in mind for opportunities, send us your resume so we have all the details that will help us help you.

About Us

Claire Kittle Dixon
Executive Director

Claire runs the day-to-day operations of Talent Market, manages searches for clients, and oversees the organization’s fundraising communications, technology, administration, and cat-herding efforts…
Read more

 

Katy Gambella
Director of Outreach

Katy oversees Talent Market’s outreach to young professionals and manages the outreach team. She also manages searches and executes outreach directly herself…
Read more

Stephanie Keaveney
Senior Manager of Outreach
Stephanie splits her time between managing talent searches for free-market nonprofits, maintaing Talent Market’s social media presence, and engaging in outreach to young professionals interested in liberty-oriented careers…
Read more

Bailey Drouant
Project Manager
Bailey assists free-market nonprofits with their hiring needs by helping them manage the search process from start to finish…
Read more

Savannah Rupp
Project Manager
Savannah channels her expertise to manage searches for free-market nonprofits, ensuring they find the perfect match to drive their missions forward. She also supports Talent Market’s…
Read more

  • Email
  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn
  • Twitter

Wait, You’re a Nonprofit?

Talent Market is a nonprofit. We’ll wait here while that sinks in. We know it’s a crazy concept, but it’s been working like a charm since 2009.

Talent Market’s mission is to promote liberty by providing talent for critical roles within the free-market nonprofit sector.

We provide consulting and recruiting services at no cost to 501(c)3 nonprofit organizations that clearly and directly focus on advancing the principles of economic freedom, free enterprise, free trade, free speech, property rights, rule of law, and limited regulation. (We do not work with political organizations, organizations with mission statements that do not clearly advance free-market principles, organizations that focus on social issues, or organizations that have a focus outside of the United States. We are not a job board. ) 

Talent Market believes that the road to prosperity is paved with freedom and that the success of our movement hinges on the talent that will take us there.

Read more

Copyright ©2025 · Talent Market

Copyright © 2025 · AgentPress Pro On Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in